An assessment of racial discrimination in the media

In a speech on cultural harmony and tolerance delivered in Brisbane on Thursday night, Soutphommasane decried the lack of non-Anglo faces on Australian television. A lack of reporters and newsreaders of colour, and few opportunities for non-Anglo actors in the entertainment industry was also a big problem, he said.

An assessment of racial discrimination in the media

This report views the effort to measure the unobserved counterfactual usually associated with experiments as necessarily being linked to a detailed understanding of the process.

Observational Studies Moving down the hierarchy with regard to rigor, especially for causal inferences, there are several intermediate steps between conducting controlled experiments and simply observing an event in an unstructured way.

Nonexperimental methods differ from those used in experiments in that the analyst cannot assign particular racial attributes to particular subjects when in a nonexperimental setting.

In observational studies, researchers have data on units at a point in time in a one-time sample survey, or longitudinally in a multiwave sample survey, or from another source e. The available data may provide reports of perceived experiences of discrimination and discriminatory attitudes.

Such data, obtained using random sampling and exhibiting low nonresponse and error rates, may allow for the external validity or generalizability that many experiments lack. However, because such survey-based studies measure subjective reports, they can be used to investigate only a limited number of phenomena related to but not measuring discrimination, such as trends in overtly discriminatory attitudes or in perceived discriminatory events see discussion in Chapter 8.

Alternatively, the available data may provide information on differential outcomes e. In such circumstances, causal inferences can be controversial. Statistical methods developed for drawing causal inferences are organized largely around trying to re-create, from observational data, the circumstances that would have occurred had controlled experimental data been collected.

These statistical methods are discussed in some detail in Chapter 7where we critically review the use of statistical models, particularly regression models, to draw valid causal inferences from observational data.

The Roles of Randomization and Manipulation Researchers justify the substitution of population-level expectations for individual-level outcomes by designing experiments that incorporate ele- Page 84 Share Cite Suggested Citation: The National Academies Press.

Executive Summary

Experiments allow us to distinguish more readily between prediction or association and causation or intervention or manipulation. To predict a random variable Y from the variable X, we attempt to measure or estimate expected values or probabilities like which is the probability that an outcome Y is equal to y, given that we have observed that some characteristic X is equal to x e.

In contrast, to infer that smoking cigarettes causes an increase in the risk of lung cancer, we attempt to measure or estimate which is the probability that an outcome Y is equal to y, given that we have an assigned value of x for the random variable X.

That is, in experiments designed to demonstrate causation, researchers manipulate X, setting its value for each experimental unit. By using different values of the quantity X for different units in the study, researchers are able to compare outcomes conditional on each value of X; thus, they are able to estimate causal effects.

In the first case, one estimates an association; in the second case, one estimates an effect. To infer a causal relationship, researchers must eliminate alternative explanations. This is an omitted variable bias problem: For example, in objecting to the hypothesized causal relationship between smoking cigarettes and lung cancer, noted statistician R.

Discrimination and the media | CRIN

This alternative explanation for the association between smoking and lung cancer was dismissed only after studies of identical twins revealed that a smoking twin was more likely to develop lung cancer than a nonsmoking twin see further discussion below.

Randomization addresses the omitted variable problem by introducing a new random quantity, R, that identifies which treatment is assigned to the unit.

By introducing the new random quantity, we set the value of X and at the same time balance on average both observed and unobserved covariates across values of X. That is, random assignment makes treatment status independent of the other covariates, both observed and unobserved.

Together, randomization and manipulation legitimize the direct causal inferences from X to Y. Again, the problem is that in the randomized experiment the unit can take only one of these values.

An assessment of racial discrimination in the media

Therefore, we cannot identify a causal effect for a specific unit.To date, the majority of studies examining experiences of racial discrimination among youth use measures initially developed for African American and Latino adults or college students. Few studies have attended to the ways in which discrimination experiences .

Unlike most editing & proofreading services, we edit for everything: grammar, spelling, punctuation, idea flow, sentence structure, & more. Get started now!

Young people tend to believe racial minority groups experience substantial discrimination in the U.S., although the extent to which they perceive discrimination varies. More than seven in ten (72%) young people say there is a lot of discrimination against black people in the U.S. today. Abstract. This study reports results from a new analysis of 17 survey experiment studies that permitted assessment of racial discrimination, drawn from the archives of . An Introduction to Racial Equity Assessment Tools Governing For Racial Equity March Terry Keleher Race Forward. About Race Forward • Race Forward advances racial justice through research, media, and practice. • Race Forward brings systemic analysis and an innovative eliminate and prevent racial discrimination and inequities. The.

The Racial Hatred Act: the media and racial hatred Subsection Title Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social Justice Age Discrimination Asylum Seekers and Refugees Children's Rights Disability Rights Race Discrimination Rights and Freedoms Sex Discrimination Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity & Intersex Status Legal International.

News analysis: Why racial discrimination is still a problem in the workplace In east Asia’s complex ethnic mix of peoples, the need to avoid racial discrimination which may undermine social stability is understood clearly by governments and businesses.

Racial discrimination is when a person is treated less favourably than another person in a similar situation because of their race, colour, descent, national or . MOSCOW (Sputnik), Alexander Mosesov — The assessment of racial discrimination in the US Army is a must for commanders at all levels, the Army Media Relations division told Sputnik on Friday.

Know your rights: Racial discrimination and vilification | Australian Human Rights Commission